Sunday, December 28, 2014

Lecture One: The Gospel of Mark - The Messianic Secret



Context of Mark

Author:

Traditionally John Mark, traveling companion of Paul and “interpreter” for Peter in Rome. The writer does not identify himself in the Gospel text, and scholars, unable to verify the late-second-century tradition of Markan authorship, regard the work as anonymous.

Date:

About 66-70 CE, during the Jewish Revolt against Rome.

Place of composition:

Rome or Syria-Palestine.

Sources:

Primarily oral tradition. Many scholars believe that Mark possibly used a few written sources, such as a collection of Jesus’ parables (ch. 4), a compilation of apocalyptic prophecies (ch. 13), and, perhaps, and older account of Jesus’ arrest, trial, and execution (chs. 14-15).

Audience:

Gentile Christians suffering persecution.

Structure of Mark

Prelude to Jesus’ Public Ministry (1:1-13)

The Galilean Ministry (1:14–8:26)

The Journey to Jerusalem (8:27–10:52)

The Jerusalem Ministry (11:1–14:11)

Mark’s Passion Narrative: Jesus’ Trial and Crucifixion (14:12–15:47)

Postlude: The Empty Tomb (16:1-8)

Later Additions to the Postlude (16:9-20)

Themes of Mark

Jesus as a “hidden Messiah” who was misunderstood and devalued by his contemporaries.

Jesus as both “Son of Man” and “Son of God.”

Jesus as servant.

Jesus came to suffer and to die.

The triumph of Jesus through submission to the will of God.

Jesus as revelator of things to come.

Jesus as teacher of the mysteries of the Kingdom.

Prelude to Jesus’ Public Ministry (1:1-13)

John the Baptist Prepares the Way (1:1-8)

“The beginning of the good news” (1:1) unique to Mark’s Gospel

Opens with quote from Isaiah 40:3…

“I will send my messenger ahead of you,
who will prepare your way”—
“a voice of one calling in the wilderness,
‘Prepare the way for the Lord,
make straight paths for him.’”

John appears in the wilderness and preaches a baptism of repentance.

Many people are baptized by John in the Jordan River.

Mark describes John as wearing clothing made of camel’s hair and a leather belt, this is supposed to remind the reader of Elijah.

John eats locusts and wild honey.

John’s message:

“After me comes the one more powerful than I, the straps of whose sandals I am not worthy to stoop down and untie. I baptize you with water, but he will baptize you with the Holy Spirit.”

John the Baptist according to puppets…


The Baptism and Testing of Jesus (1:9-13)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 3:13–4:11

Jesus is baptized by John and then led into the wilderness to be tempted.

Jesus being with the wild beasts during temptations (1:13) unique to Mark’s Gospel.

Mark also says Jesus was attended by angels.

The Galilean Ministry (1:14–8:26)

Jesus Announces the Good News (1:14-15)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 4:12-17

John gets arrested.

Jesus goes to Galilee and preaches.

“The time has come,” he said. “The kingdom of God has come near. Repent and believe the good news!”

Jesus Calls His First Disciples (1:16-20)

Covered more thoroughly in Luke 5:1-11

Jesus sees Simon and Andrew fishing on the Sea of Galilee and calls to them to follow Him so He can teach them to fish for people.

They follow without hesitation.

James and John do the same, leaving their father and his boat behind.

Jesus Drives Out an Impure Spirit (1:21-28)

Jesus teaches at the synagogue in Capernaum on the Sabbath.

The people are impressed with Jesus’ knowledge.

A man with an evil spirit starts screaming at Jesus.

He says, “What do you want with us, Jesus of Nazareth? Have you come to destroy us? I know who you are—the Holy One of God!”

Jesus tells the demon to shut up, and casts it out of the man.

The demon shrieks and shakes the man as it leaves him.

After this, news about Jesus begins to spread all around the region of Galilee.

Jesus Heals Many (1:29-34)

Jesus and his disciples leave the synagogue and go to Simon and Andrew’s house.

Simon’s mother-in-law is sick in bed, and Jesus takes her by the hand, heals her, and helps her out of bed.

She then feeds them all as people begin to show up at the door to be healed.

Jesus casts out even more demons and refuses to let them speak.

Jesus Prays in a Solitary Place (1:35-39)

Jesus gets up before sunrise to go pray by himself.

Simon and the others find and say, “Everyone’s looking for you!”

Jesus decides they need to move on to other towns for awhile, so they do.

Jesus Heals a Man with Leprosy (1:40-45)

A man with leprosy comes to Jesus and says, “If you are willing, you can make me clean.”

Jesus says, “I am willing.”

Jesus heals him tells him not to tell anyone and simply to go fulfill the Mosaic Law’s requirements for healings.

Instead, the man goes out and tells everyone he meets.

Jesus can no longer stay in towns because of this, and from now on he and his disciples sleep outside in “lonely places.”

Jesus Forgives and Heals a Paralyzed Man (2:1-12)

Jesus returns to Capernaum and preaches in a house.

The Paralyzed Man according to puppets…


The house is filled to overflowing, so that people cannot get to Jesus.


Some men cut a hole in the roof and lower their paralyzed friend down so that Jesus can heal him.

Jesus says, “Son, your sins are forgiven.”

The teachers of the law didn’t care for that statement, and thought Jesus was being blasphemous.

Jesus knew what they were thinking, and says to them which is easier to say – “Your sins are forgiven” or “Get up and walk”?

He then heals the man just to prove that He has the authority to forgive peoples’ sins.

Jesus Calls Levi and Eats with Sinners (2:13-17)

Jesus is walking by the lake with crowds following him when he sees Levi sitting at the tax collector’s booth.

He calls Levi, and Levi follows him.

He later eats dinner at Levi’s house and the Pharisees disapprove of him eating with “sinners.”

Jesus turns their views on their heads, saying, “It is not the healthy who need a doctor, but the sick. I have not come to call the righteous, but sinners.”

Jesus Questioned About Fasting (2:18-22)

Covered more thoroughly in Luke 5:33-39

Jesus Is Lord of the Sabbath (2:23-28)

Jesus and is disciples are walking through a grain field on the Sabbath, and the disciples start picking heads of grain.

The Pharisees accuse them of breaking Mosaic Law.

Jesus reminds them that even King David broke the Law by eating the sacred bread when he and his men were starving to death.

Jesus turns again turns their views on their heads, saying, “Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath, so the Son of Man is lord of Sabbath.”

Jesus Heals on the Sabbath (3:1-6)

Jesus goes to the synagogue on the Sabbath and sees a man with a shriveled hand

The Pharisees were watching to see if He would heal on the Sabbath.

Jesus has the man stand in front of everyone, and asks them all “Which is better, to save life or to kill?”

Nobody says anything.

Jesus becomes angry, and he turns and heals the man.

The Pharisees then go out and plot Jesus’ death with the Herodians.

Crowds Follow Jesus (3:7-12)

Jesus and his disciples withdraw to the Lake, and crowds from all over follow them.

He heals people and casts out demons.

The demons would say, “You are the Son of God.” But Jesus would order them not to speak about that

Jesus Appoints the Twelve (3:13-19)

Calling disciples to mountain to preach, and cast out demons (3:13-15) unique to Mark’s Gospel

These are the twelve:

Simon (to whom he gave the name Peter)

James, son of Zebedee

John, brother of James

James and John being given the name “Boanerges", meaning "sons of Thunder” (3:17) unique to Mark’s Gospel

Andrew

Phillip

Bartholomew

Matthew

Thomas

James, son of Alphaeus

Thaddaeus

Simon the Zealot

Judas (who betrayed him)

Jesus Accused by His Family and by Teachers of the Law (3:20-35)

Jesus and his disciples go to house, and so many people show up that they can’t even eat.

Jesus’ family thinks he’s crazy, and come to take charge of him.

Jesus’ family trying to restrain him (3:20-21) unique to Mark’s Gospel

The teachers of the Law arrive from Jerusalem and they accuse Jesus of casting out demons by the power of Beelzebul.

Jesus begins to speak in parables:

“How can Satan drive out Satan? If a kingdom is divided against itself, that kingdom cannot stand. If a house is divided against itself, that house cannot stand. And if Satan opposes himself and is divided, he cannot stand; his end has come. In fact, no one can enter a strong man’s house without first tying him up. Then he can plunder the strong man’s house. Truly I tell you, people can be forgiven all their sins and every slander they utter, but whoever blasphemes against the Holy Spirit will never be forgiven; they are guilty of an eternal sin.”

Someone interrupts Jesus to let him know that his mother and brothers have arrived to take him home.

Jesus responds, “Who are my mother and my brothers?”

He then identifies those sitting in a circle around him – the ones who do the will of God – as his true family.

The Parable of the Sower (4:1-20)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 13:1-23

A Lamp on a Stand (4:21-25)

“Do you bring in a lamp to put it under a bowl or a bed? Instead, don’t you put it on its stand? For whatever is hidden is meant to be disclosed, and whatever is concealed is meant to be brought out into the open.”

This parable can also be used to explain the confusing idea of the “Messianic secret.” All secrets are ultimately intended to be revealed – including the secret of Jesus as Messiah.

“With the measure you use, it will be measured to you—and even more. Whoever has will be given more; whoever does not have, even what they have will be taken from them.”

The Parable of the Growing Seed (4:26-29)

“This is what the kingdom of God is like. A man scatters seed on the ground. Night and day, whether he sleeps or gets up, the seed sprouts and grows, though he does not know how. All by itself the soil produces grain—first the stalk, then the head, then the full kernel in the head. As soon as the grain is ripe, he puts the sickle to it, because the harvest has come.”



The Parable of the Mustard Seed (4:30-34)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 13:31-35

Jesus Calms the Storm (4:35-41)

At the end of a long day, Jesus and his disciples sail across the Lake away from the crowds.

Jesus falls asleep.

A storm quickly comes upon them, but Jesus sleeps through it.

Jesus being asleep on a cushion during storm (4:38) unique to Mark’s Gospel

As the waves are breaking over the boat, the disciples wake Jesus up, saying, “Don’t you care if we drown?”

Jesus gets up and tells the wind and the waves to shut up.

Jesus saying, “Peace, Be still” to the storm (4:39) unique to Mark’s Gospel

The storm immediately stops, and Jesus asks the disciples why they were so afraid, and what happened to their faith.

The disciples are terrified, and they wonder who this man could be… because they just don’t get it.


Jesus Restores a Demon-Possessed Man (5:1-20)

They cross the Lake and arrive in the region of the Gerasenes.

The text says that when Jesus got out of the boat, a man with a demon came running out of the tombs towards him.

The text describes the man as living in the tombs, and one who was unable to be restrained, even by chains.

The text says that he would break his chains, and would stay at the tombs at night crying out and cutting himself with stones.

Details about strength of Gerasene demoniac (5:4-5) unique to Mark’s Gospel

Jesus commands the demon to come out of the man.

The man falls at his knees in front of Jesus, screaming, “What do you want with me, Jesus, Son of the Most High God? In God’s name don’t torture me!”

Jesus asks, “What’s your name?”

He responds, “My name is Legion, for we are many.”

He begs over and over for Jesus not to send them out of the area.

The demons request to be relocated to a nearby heard of pigs.

Jesus gives them permission, and they all leave the man and go into the pigs.

The pigs go crazy, and the whole heard jumps off a cliff and drowns in the Lake.

The Lake was also referred to as “the pit” by the people who lived near it, and they believed it was where Satan himself lived in chaos and darkness.

So when the pigs jump into the Lake, the text is implying that even these “unclean animals” understood that these “unclean spirits” belonged in hell.

The man is restored to his right mind, and puts on some clothes.

The pig farmers are afraid of Jesus, and beg him to leave the area.

The people now acts as the demons, begging for Jesus to leave them alone.

The man now healed begs to go with Jesus, but Jesus tells him he should go home and tell his people just how much Jesus had done for him... which is quite the opposite command of the Messianic Secret that we normally see from Jesus when he's among his fellow Jews.

The man begins to preach in The Decapolis (The Ten Cities) about Jesus.

Jesus Raises a Dead Girl and Heals a Sick Woman (5:21-43)

Jesus crosses the Lake again and the crowds are waiting for him.

A man named Jairus, a synagogue leader begs Jesus to come heal his sick twelve year old daughter.

On the way, Jesus is pressed by the large crowds.

A woman is in the crowd who had been bleeding for twelve years.

She believes that if she could only touch the “corners” or “wings” of Jesus’ garment, she would be healed.

This thought refers back to the prophet Malachi, who said, “The Sun of Righteousness will rise with healing in his wings.”

She touches the “wings” and is healed.

Jesus suddenly stops, knowing something is different.

He asks, “Who touched my clothes?”

The disciples think he’s being weird, and respond, “You’re in a crowd. Everyone’s touching your clothes.”

Jesus being aware that power had gone from him when healing woman with bleeding (5:30) unique to Mark’s Gospel

The woman comes forward and fearfully confesses.

Jesus says to her, “Your faith has healed you.”

While Jesus is talking, someone shows up and informs Jairus that his daughter just died.

Jesus says, “Don’t be afraid; just believe.”

Jesus takes his closest friends, Peter, James, and John, with him to Jairus’s house.

There is a large crowd wailing, and Jesus tells them to stop wailing because the girl is “only asleep.”

The crowd laughs at Jesus and Jesus sends them away.

Jesus goes in to see the girl, takes her by the hand, and tells her to get up, and she does.

The parents and the disciples are shocked, and Jesus tells them to feed the girl, and to not tell anyone about what had just happened – it must be a secret.

A Prophet Without Honor (6:1-6a)

Covered more thoroughly in Luke 4:14-30

Jesus Sends Out the Twelve (6:6b-13)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 10:1-42

Jesus teaches in various villages.

Sends his disciples out in twos to go do what he’s been doing.

John the Baptist Beheaded (6:14-29)

Mark lets his readers know that King Herod heard about everything Jesus and his disciples were doing.

Some people were saying that Jesus was really John the Baptist come back from the dead, but Herod would have none of that nonsense.

Mark then backtracks here and tells his readers the story of how Herod had killed John the Baptist.

Herod had married his brother Phillip’s wife, Herodius, and John had told him that was a wicked thing to do, so Herod locked John up in prison.

Herod enjoyed listening to John preach, but Herodius hated John.

When Herod’s birthday came, he had a big party, and Herodius’s daughter Salome danced for everyone.

Herod was so “pleased” by her that he promised to give her anything she wanted.

Salome discussed this with her mother, and her mother sent her back to request for the head of John the Baptist to be served on a silver platter.

Herod didn’t want to kill John, but also didn’t want to look bad in front of his guests for breaking his oath, so he had John beheaded.

John’s disciples placed John’s body in a tomb.

Jesus Feeds the Five Thousand (6:30-44)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 14:13-21

Jesus Walks on the Water (6:45-56)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 14:22-36

That Which Defiles (7:1-23)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 15:1-20

Jesus Honors a Syrophoenician Woman’s Faith (7:24-30)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 15:21-28

Departure to Tyre, and entering a house, not wanting anyone to know he was there (7:24) unique to Mark’s Gospel

Jesus Heals a Deaf and Mute Man (7:31-37)

Jesus has been traveling with his disciples through pagan territory.

He leaves Tyre and Sidon and goes to the Decapolis (Ten Cities).

People beg him to heal a deaf and mute man.

“Jesus put his fingers into the man’s ears. Then he spit and touched the man’s tongue. He looked up to heaven and with a deep sigh said to him, ’Ephphatha!’ (which means ’Be opened!’). At this, the man’s ears were opened, his tongue was loosened and he began to speak plainly.”

Jesus keeps telling people to stop spreading the word about him, but they keep doing it anyway.

Jesus Feeds the Four Thousand (8:1-13)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 15:29-39

The Yeast of the Pharisees and Herod (8:14-21)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 16:5-12

Jesus Heals a Blind Man at Bethsaida (8:22-26)

Jesus and his disciples arrive at Bethsaida and the people bring him a blind man.

Jesus secretly spits on the man’s eyes and asks him what he sees.

The man says he says people that look like walking trees.

Jesus tries again and this time the man can see everything clearly.

Jesus tells him to keep this a secret and not to even avoid going back into town.

The blind man can represent the people, who even after having seen the Messiah do not understand what they are looking at… but who will one day understand fully.

This is one possible reason why Jesus insists on a temporary Messianic secret. Because the people don’t really know what a messiah is, and with their confused and ecstatic words they have been spreading a false gospel about Jesus.

The Journey to Jerusalem (8:27–10:52)

Peter Declares That Jesus Is the Messiah (8:27-30)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 16:13-20

Jesus Predicts His Death (8:31-33)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 16:21-28

The Way of the Cross (8:34–9:1)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 16:21-28

The Transfiguration (9:2-13)

Jesus takes Peter, James, and John up a mountain.

His appearance changes in front of them and his clothes become bright white.

Suddenly Moses and Elijah of long ago appear out of nowhere and begin speaking with Jesus.

Peter doesn’t know what to say and he interrupts the conversation and volunteers to build three huts for them.

Mark writes, “Then a cloud appeared and covered them, and a voice came from the cloud: ‘This is my Son, whom I love. Listen to him!’”

Luke’s version puts it this way: “This is my Son, whom I have chosen; listen to him.”

This is a direct reference to three different passages from the three different sections of the Hebrew Bible – The Torah, the Nevi’im, and the Khetuvim – showing that Jesus is the focal point all of the Law (Moses) and the Prophets (Elijah) …and even the poets.

Through the poets God declares in Psalm 2:7, “You are my son, today I have begotten you.”

Through the prophets God declares in Isaiah 42:1a, “Here is my servant, whom I support, my chosen one, in whom I take pleasure.”

And through the Law of Moses God declares in Deuteronomy 18:15, “The Lord your God will raise up for you a prophet like me from among you, from your fellow Israelites. You must listen to him.”

Moses and Elijah are gone and Jesus tells Peter, James, and John not to tell anyone what they saw until after He was raised from the dead.

They are confused about what he meant by rising from the dead… proving that they were not yet ready to spread the true Gospel of Jesus.

They also ask about Elijah’s return and Jesus’ opinion on that biblical teaching. Jesus responds with a question, “Why then is it written that the Son of Man must suffer much and be rejected?”

He then indicates that Elijah already came back and the teachers of Law did whatever they pleased with him.

Jesus Heals a Boy Possessed by an Impure Spirit (9:14-29)

They come down the mountain and meet up with the other disciples who are in the middle of an argument with the teachers of the Law over a demon-possessed boy.

The crowd is amazed when Jesus arrives, and Jesus just wants to know what the ruckus is all about.

The boy’s father explains his son’s condition – how the demon tries to throw the boy into fire or water to kill him ever since he was a child, and how he “foams at the mouth, gnashes his teeth, and becomes rigid.”

The disciples were unable to help the boy, so that man asks for Jesus’ help if Jesus is able to help.

Jesus is like, “‘If’? What do you mean ‘if I can help’? Everything is possible for the believer!”

The father quickly changes his attitude, declaring, “I do believe; help me overcome my unbelief!”

A crowd is running over to watch, so Jesus starts chewing out the demon, commanding it to leave and never return.

The demon shrieks and violently shakes the boy and then comes out.

The crowd thought the boy was dead, but Jesus took him by the hand and helped him up.

Later, the disciples wanted to know why they couldn’t drive out the demon, and Jesus tells them that this kind can only come out by prayer and fasting.

Jesus Predicts His Death a Second Time (9:30-37)

Jesus walks his disciples through Galilee and teaches them.

He tells them “The Son of Man is going to be delivered into the hands of men. They will kill him, and after three days he will rise.”

But they didn’t understand and were afraid to ask what he meant.

When they arrive at Capernaum, Jesus lets them know that he overheard them arguing about which one of them was the greatest.

He sits down and once again turns everything on its head by saying, “Anyone who wants to be first must be the very last, and the servant of all.”

He holds a child and says to them, “Whoever welcomes one of these little children in my name welcomes me; and whoever welcomes me does not welcome me but the one who sent me.”

Whoever Is Not Against Us Is for Us (9:38-41)

John tattles to Jesus about some folks he saw driving out demons in Jesus’ name, saying they told them to stop.

Jesus is like, “Why did you tell them to stop? We’re on the same team!”

Causing to Stumble (9:42-50)

Jesus goes back to the child, saying, “If anyone causes one of these little ones—those who believe in me—to stumble, it would be better for them if a large millstone were hung around their neck and they were thrown into the sea.”

He then goes on to say if their hand or their foot or eye causes them to sin, they should cut it off and get rid of it. Because it’s better to be crippled and live, than to have two feet in hell (or Gehenna).

Some observations about Gehenna from this passage:

“All of Jesus’ references to gehenna are made to religious people, and are made in reference to sinful behavior. None of them are spoken to unbelievers or in reference specifically about unbelievers – and for that matter, none are made in reference to one’s lack of belief or orthodoxy.”

“All of the references to gehenna can be reasonably viewed as references to the literal location – a burning garbage dump, where bodies are filled with maggots (worms that, to the ancients, appeared to have come from nowhere and do not die – transforming, instead, into flies) and are consumed in the flames.”

The Hinnom Valley (Gehenna) today

“If we look specifically at the passage from Mark, which is the one most often quoted by those supporting a view of gehenna as a place of eternal, conscious punishment, Jesus refers to it as “where ‘the worms that eat them do not die, and the fire is not quenched.’” This is a direct quote from Isaiah 66, where the prophet describes the view of the fallen Assyrian army (in the Hinnom Valley… or ‘Hell Valley’ in rough English) ‘And they will go out and look on the dead bodies of those who rebelled against me; the worms that eat them will not die, the fire that burns them will not be quenched, and they will be loathsome to all mankind.’ It is a view of dead bodies on a funeral pyre, full of maggots, being burned to ash.”

Jesus then says, “Everyone will be salted with fire. Salt is good, but if it loses its saltiness, how can you make it salty again? Have salt among yourselves, and be at peace with each other.”

Divorce (10:1-12)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 19:1-12

The Little Children and Jesus (10:13-16)

People were bringing little children to Jesus for him to place his hands on them, but the disciples rebuked them.

Jesus didn’t like this and said to them, “Let the little children come to me, and do not hinder them, for the kingdom of God belongs to such as these. Truly I tell you, anyone who will not receive the kingdom of God like a little child will never enter it.”

And he took the children in his arms, placed his hands on them and blessed them.

Jesus being indignant when disciples sent children away (10:14) unique to Mark’s Gospel

The Rich and the Kingdom of God (10:17-31)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 19:16-30

Blessings include persecutions for those who give up everything (10:30) unique to Mark’s Gospel

Jesus Predicts His Death a Third Time (10:32-34)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 20:17-19

The Request of James and John (10:35-45)

Covered more thoroughly in Matthew 20:20-28

Blind Bartimaeus Receives His Sight (10:46-52)

Jesus and his disciples go to Jericho and the crowds follow them.

A blind man named Bartimaeus (or “the son of Timaeus”) hears that jesus of Nazareth has arrived and he begins calling out to him, “Son of David! Have mercy on me!”

Jesus stops and has the man brought to him.

The man stands up and leaves his cloak behind him as he goes to Jesus.

Jesus asks him what he wants, and he says, “Rabbi, I want to see.”

Jesus says, “Go, your faith has healed you.”

The man’s sight was restored immediately and he followed Jesus down the road. 









______________________________________________________________

Sources

Stephen L. Harris. The New Testament: A Student's Introduction (6th ed.). McGraw-Hill: New York, NY, 2009.

Lyons, Christopher. What the Hell? Fishing the Abyss, 2011.












Sunday, December 14, 2014

Lecture Six: Other Gospels


Other Gospels

Contrasting Portrayals of Jesus 

Besides the four canonical Gospels, early Christian writers produced numerous other Gospels, each with a distinctive perspective on Jesus’ teachings and theological significance. 

The noncanonical Gospels reflect the wide range of viewpoints about Jesus that prevailed in the early churches. 

The only work to survive complete, the Gospel of Thomas contains many sayings thought to derive from the historical Jesus, as well as later Gnostic interpolations. 

Fragmental works, such as the Gospel of Judas, Secret Mark, and the Gospel of Peter, explore, respectively, the mysteries of Jesus’ private discourse and his resurrection. 

While the “pre-Gospel” account ascribed to James preserves legendary material about Jesus’ family, the Infancy Gospel of Thomas imaginatively records legends about Jesus’ childhood.

The Gospel of Thomas

“Unlike the canonical Gospels, the Gospel of Thomas contains no narrative of Jesus’ miracles or other deeds; it consists solely of 114 sayings.”

“According to the opening statement, ‘These are the secret sayings that the living Jesus spoke and Didymos Judas Thomas recorded.’”

“The sayings are ‘secret’ because their true meaning is evident only to those who can understand them correctly, a life-giving ‘interpretation’ that saves spiritually aware persons from ‘tasting death.’”

“John’s Gospel, which shares several themes with the Gospel of Thomas, makes similar connections between knowing Jesus’ message and achieving immortality.”

The Author

“The ‘Didymos Judas Thomas’ credited with compiling Jesus’ words is commonly identified with the Thomas who appears prominently in John’s Gospel.” 

“Because both ‘Didymos’ (a Greek term) and ‘Thomas’ (an Aramaic word) mean ‘twin,’ it seems significant that John’s Thomas is repeatedly identified as ‘the Twin.’” 

However, “according to the non-canonical Acts of Thomas, ‘Judas Thomas’ is the same Judas (Jude) whom Mark names as one of Jesus’ ‘brothers’ (Mark 6:3), and thus the twin of Jesus himself!” 

“Because this claim of Thomas’s unique connection to Jesus appears nowhere in the New Testament or in any other credible source, scholars do not take it seriously.” 

“The Gospel of Thomas reserves its highest praise, not for Thomas, but for another of Jesus’ brothers, James.” 

“When the disciples ask Jesus who their leader will be after Jesus’ departure, he replies that wherever the disciples are they must consult ‘James the Just, for whose sake heaven and earth came into being.’”

Contents 

“There are approximately 79 statements (out of the 114 into which scholars have divided the text) that resemble passages in the Synoptics, as well as some imagery and themes that otherwise appear only in John.”

Examples of easy-to-understand quotes which resemble the Synoptic sayings:

“No prophet is welcome on his home turf.”

“One who seeks will find, and for [one who knocks] it will be opened.”

“If you have money, don’t lend it at interest. Rather, give [it] to someone from whom you won’t get it back.”

Examples of confusing quotes unlike anything found in the canonical Gospels:

“When the disciples ask Jesus how their ‘end’ will come, Jesus replies:

“Have you found the beginning, then, that you are looking for the end? You see, the end will be where the beginning is. Congratulations to the one who stands at the beginning; that one will know the end and will not taste death.”

When the disciples ask about Jesus’ Second Coming, Jesus answers:

“When you strip without being ashamed, and you take your clothes and put them under your feet like little children and trample them, then [you] will see the son of the living one and you will not be afraid.”

In Thomas, Jesus is not a savior, however, in one rare statement Jesus appears to associate himself with the source of divine light: 

“I am the light that is over all things. I am all: from me all came forth, and to me all attained. Split a piece of wood; I am there. Lift up the stone, and you will find me there.” 

In the Synoptics, when Jesus asks, “Who do people say I am?” his followers offer a variety of suggestions, culminating in Peter’s recognition that he is the Messiah. Thomas’s Jesus phrases the question differently, asking them, in effect, to make a parable of him: “Compare me to something and tell me what I am like.” 

The disciples’ responses also vary, with Peter comparing Jesus to a ‘just angel” and Matthew comparing him to a “wise philosopher.” But when Thomas confesses that he is “utterly unable to say what [Jesus] is like,” Jesus is apparently pleased, observing that he is no longer Thomas’s “teacher,” because Thomas has already drunk from “the bubbling spring that [Jesus] has tended,” successfully internalizing the Master’s teaching. 

Jesus then speaks privately with Thomas, confiding “three sayings” that Thomas later tells his fellow disciples are so offensive that they would stone him if he repeated them. 

One of the most problematic sayings in Thomas is the last. It has no parallel in the canonical Gospels and is almost certainly not from the historical Jesus, yet it likely reflects a controversial issue affecting many branches of the Christian community. Here, Peter is represented as trying to banish Mary from the circle of disciples, ‘for females don’t deserve life.’ Jesus permits Mary to remain in the group, but says: 

“Look, I will guide her to make her male, so that she too may become a living spirit resembling you males. For every female who makes herself male will enter the domain of Heaven.” 

In the New Testament, the authors of 1 Peter and the pastoral epistles voice similar opinions, urging the subordination of women to male leaders. 

In an earlier Thomas saying about the necessity of transcending gender, the principle of transformation is applied to both sexes, who are to become like “nursing babies” in order to enter the kingdom: 

“Jesus said to them, ‘When you make the two into one, and when you make the inner like the outer and the outer like the inner, and the upper like the lower, and when you make the male and female into a single one, so that the male will not be male nor the female be female, when you make… an image in place of an image, then you will enter [the (Father’s) domain].” 

“In Thomas, Jesus’ redemptive work is accomplished through his teaching rather than his death, a factor that probably helps to explain why the mainstream church, with its emerging orthodoxy, did not preserve the Gospel.” 

The Gospel of Judas

Lost for almost 1,700 years, a papyrus manuscript of the Gospel of Judas was probably discovered in a cave near El Minya, Egypt, about 1978, after which it passed anonymously through the hands of various antiquities dealers.

Its identity and value were not generally recognized, and for sixteen years, it lay crumbling in a safety deposit box in New York until it was handed over to scholars in 2001.

Although scholars had long known that a Gospel of Judas once existed – the church leader Irenaeus of Lyon had denounced it as heretical in 180 CE – no one knew its contents.

Composed originally in Greek about 140-160 CE and translated into Coptic about 290-300 CE, the Gospel portrays Judas Iscariot as radically different from the canonical Gospels.

Rather than a false disciple who betrays Jesus to his enemies for personal gain, in the Coptic text, many scholars believe, Judas is portrayed as Jesus’ truest friend, a man of spiritual stature exceeding that of the other apostles.

Gnostic Controversy 

The unknown author of the Gospel of Judas expounds a variant of early Christianity known as Sethian Gnosticism, which postulates a dualistic universe containing many ranks of spirit beings.

According to this view, the true God – which Jesus teaches Judas to seek – has nothing to do with the physical world, which is deeply the flawed creation of the imperfect biblical deity, Yahweh, and is the source of ignorance, death, and corruption.

Unlike Judas, to whom Jesus has imparted knowledge (gnosis) and spiritual enlightenment, the other disciples can recognize only “their god [the biblical Yahweh],” misleading them to found a church modeled on their misunderstanding of true divinity.

In the Judas Gospel, salvation comes not because Jesus gives his life to pay for human sins, but because Jesus reveals the sacredness of the divine spark that dwells in many human souls and shows persons so endowed the way to discover the supreme God.

More Controversy

Some scholars, however, challenge the notion that this Gnostic Gospel actually places Judas in a positive light. 

April DeConick argues that the National Geographic edition mistranslates the word daimon as “spirit” rather than “demon” (the text calls Judas the “thirteenth daimon”) and that the translators omitted a crucial negative (Judas “will not ascend to the holy generation”), proposing that the Coptic writer portrays Judas as an evil figure. 

According to this interpretation, Judas is actually serving a malign god when he turns Jesus over to be crucified. 

The Gospel writer is not trying to rehabilitate Judas, but perhaps seeking to show a Gnostic Jesus mocking his errant disciple’s self-deceptions. 

Because the Judas manuscript is so poorly preserved, with many gaps and missing passages, scholarly controversies over the Gospel’s interpretation are likely to continue. 

The Gospel of Secret Mark

Discovered in 1958 by New Testament scholar Morton Smith while cataloging manuscripts at the Mar Saba monastery near Jerusalem, Secret Mark describes Jesus’ resuscitation of a rich young man, to whom he later privately teaches “the mystery of God’s domain.” 

Whereas many scholars judge the work a forgery, others defend its authenticity. 

If genuine, Secret Mark may preserve an early version of John’s famous account of the raising of Lazarus, indicating that this miracle story was also once part of the Synoptic tradition. 

The narrative parts of Secret Mark are quotations in a letter purportedly written about 200 CE by Clement of Alexandria, a prominent church leader. 

According to Morton Smith, Clement’s letter – the existence of which was previously unknown – was transcribed around 1750 on the blank pages of a book in the monastery library. 

In Clement’s letter to a Christian named Theodore, he states that, after composing his Gospel for the general public, Mark wrote a revised version for more spiritually mature believers, including Jesus’ esoteric teachings about God’s kingdom. 

The longer of the two excerpts, Clement notes, appeared between canonical Mark 10:34 and 10:35.

In the context of Secret Mark, the youth whom Jesus revives may have been the same wealthy young man to whom Jesus’ “heart [had] warmed” a few verses earlier in the same chapter. 

Upon rising from the tomb, “the young man looked at Jesus, loved him, and began to beg to be with him.” 

Six days later, Jesus summons the youth, “dressed only in a linen cloth,” to “[spend] the night with him,” during which time Jesus “taught him the mystery of God’s domain” – the same phrase translated as “the secret of the kingdom of God” in canonical Mark 4:11. 

A similar nocturnal ritual, perhaps involving a baptism, may explain the presence in canonical Mark of a “young man with nothing on but a linen cloth and [running] away naked,” an incident that appears only in Mark’s Gospel (14:51-52). 

Some commentators suggest that this unnamed disciple at Gethsemane is the same as the “youth sitting on the right-hand side [of Jesus’ empty tomb], wearing a white robe,” who announces Jesus’ resurrection on the first Easter Sunday (Mark 16:5-7). 

At present, many in the scholarly community are still weighing the evidence for and against the authenticity of Secret Mark. If a majority eventually agrees that Clement’s letter is genuine – and that he does indeed quote from a subsequently lost edition of Mark – we may have not only a precedent for the resuscitation of Lazarus but perhaps also a clue to the identity of “the disciple [Jesus] loved” (John 11:35-36; 13:13-23).

The Gospel of Peter

Found in 1886, the extant portion is a Passion account, dramatically narrating Jesus’ trial, crucifixion, burial, and resurrection. 

Because of the manuscript’s fragmentary state, we do not know if the original Gospel also included a report on Jesus’ public ministry and miracles; the narrative ends abruptly with Peter fishing at the Sea of Galilee, apparently about to witness an appearance of the risen Lord. 

The Gospel of Peter resembles Matthew’s Gospel in many respects, including the story of Pilate’s posting Roman soldiers to guard Jesus’ grave, but it contains even more spectacularly supernatural, even bizarre, phenomena. 

Late Saturday night, while Pilate’s guards watch in awe, the predawn heavens part, and two celestial beings descend to earth in a blaze of light and cause the massive stone that sealed the tomb entrance to roll away. 

The transformed Jesus then emerges from the sepulcher, supported on each side by the two celestial beings, whose heads reach the sky. Standing even taller than his angelic companions, Jesus’ head “reached beyond the skies.” 

When a heavenly voice asks if Christ has brought his message to the subterranean realm of the dead, a cross, the fourth figure in Jesus’ triumphal procession, testifies that he has.

Although scholars agree that the historical Peter had nothing to do with the Gospel attributed to him, they are sharply divided about the document’s importance to the Jesus tradition. 

In the extant version, the Gospel exhibits several Gnostic touches. 

Jesus’ silence during the Crucifixion intimates that (as pure spirit) he does not feel physical pain. 

Also, instead of lamenting that God has forsaken him (as in Mark and Matthew), he complains that his “Power” has deserted him (perhaps indicating the departure of the supernatural Being that had previously dwelt within him). 

Jesus’ death, moreover, is expressed euphemistically, for he is described as “taken up,” implying a divine rescue or escape into the spirit world. 

The cross’s testimony that Jesus devoted the interval between his (assumed) death and visible resurrection to preaching in the netherworld also suggests that this Gospel’s author saw Jesus’ spiritual existence, in this life and the next, as a continuum. 

The two canonical letters ascribed to Peter also refer to Jesus’ postmortem activities in the Underworld (1 Pet. 3:19; 4:6; 2 Pet. 2:4). 

The Infancy Gospel of Thomas

During the second century, curiosity about Jesus’ boyhood prompted several narratives that attempted to fill in the “missing years” of Jesus’ youth. 

The Infancy Gospel of Thomas (ca. 150 CE) is ascribed to the apostle Thomas. 

Unrelated to the Gospel of Thomas, this account of incidents from Jesus’ childhood uncritically incorporates popular legends and speculations about the Messiah’s youthful character and behavior. 

Opening with anecdotes about the five-year-old Jesus performing mischievous tricks in his home village, the Gospel closes with a retelling of Luke’s story about Jesus, at age twelve, visiting the Temple in Jerusalem. 

It says nothing, however, about Jesus’ young manhood, leaving blank the eighteen years that pass before the adult Jesus comes to John for baptism. 

Modern readers are likely to be perplexed by the Infancy Gospel’s portrait of Jesus, who as a mere child possesses God-like powers that he at first seems too inexperienced or undisciplined to use wisely.

Acutely aware that he merits respect and deference from everyone, the young Jesus is easily angered by even casual slights and, repeatedly, employs his superhuman abilities to punish the offenders. 

When a playmate disrupts pools of water that Jesus had formed in a stream, he furiously curses the child, withering him into a state of premature aging. 

When another boy, running through the village, accidentally bumps into Jesus, Jesus strikes him dead. 

After the dead boy’s parents demand that Joseph teach his son to bless people rather than to curse them, and Joseph privately warns Jesus about the negative effects of his conduct, Jesus causes those who criticized him to go blind.

When his first teacher, Zaccheus, tries to instruct Jesus in the alphabet, he calls his master a “hypocrite” for not knowing all the “allegorical” traditions surrounding each letter. 

After totally demoralizing Zaccheus, an old man “conquered by a child,” Jesus is sent to another teacher, who makes the mistake of hitting Jesus on the head for speaking impertinently. The boy’s curse sends the man crashing to the ground in an apparent paralytic stroke. 


Jesus’ third teacher, “a good friend of Joseph,” who evidently has learned from the experiences of his predecessors, does not presume to instruct his charge but instead wins Jesus’ approval by praising the boy, recognizing that he is “full of much grace and wisdom.” Because his new instructor has perceived and honored Jesus’ divine nature, the boy lifts the curse from his previous teachers. 

Jesus’ neighbors in Nazareth are appalled at his antics, for he is, literally, a holy terror. 

They ask Joseph, “What kind of child do you have who does such things?” 

Joseph privately tells Mary not to let Jesus out of the house "because anyone who angers him dies.” 

As Jesus grows somewhat older, however, the beneficial aspects of his powers begin to outweigh the destructive. 

After his public shaming of Zaccheus, “all those who had fallen under his curse” are healed, and Jesus begins a series of miraculous cures and resuscitations.

When a playmate dies after falling off a roof and Jesus is held responsible, he revives the boy to testify his innocence. 

He also heals a young woodcutter whose misplaced axe blow had nearly severed his foot and saves his brother James from death by a poisonous snake bite. 

In the last two reported miracles, Jesus resuscitates a dead child and a deceased workman. 

Witnessing these deeds, the villagers now recognize Jesus’ special status: “This is a heavenly child, for he saved many souls from death, and can save them all his life.”

In the Infancy Gospel’s first episode, Jesus had “profaned” the Sabbath by shaping twelve sparrows from clay, technically violating the commandment to refrain from all work on the day of rest. 

When Joseph confronts him, Jesus claps his hands and, instantly, the twelve clay birds fly away, removing the evidence of his misdemeanor. 

In the Gospel’s final event, set in the Temple, Jesus’ precocity has deepened into a wisdom that foreshadows the man he will become. 

Seated in the sanctuary, amid the “elders and teachers of the people,” Jesus “grew in wisdom…and grace,” perhaps suggesting that even God’s son – future judge of all humanity – underwent a learning process characteristic of the human condition.

The Infancy Gospel of James

Also called the Book of James or Protoevangelium of James, this Gospel supplies background information on Jesus’ parents and family, covering events that occurred up to and including his birth. 

Based partly on the infancy accounts in Matthew and Luke and partly on oral tradition, this prologue to Jesus’ life story may include a few historical facts among its purely legendary components. 

The work states that its author is James, who in this Gospel is identified as Jesus’ older stepbrother, the son of Joseph by a former marriage. 

The story focuses on the personal history of Mary, Jesus’ future mother, who is born to a previously childless couple – Joachim, a wealthy herdsman, and his wife, Anna. 

At age three, Mary is taken to the Jerusalem Temple, where she is raised by priests until her sexual maturation makes her ritually impure and disqualifies her from dwelling in the sanctuary. 

The priests then consign the twelve-year-old Mary to the care of Joseph, a widower with children, who functions as her guardian and strictly respects her virginity.

The genealogies in Matthew and Luke both trace Jesus’ Davidic ancestry through his presumed father, Joseph. 

In contrast, the Infancy Gospel of James states that Mary, too, descended from David. 

Thus, her virgin-born son inherits his messianic heritage directly from her. 

Written during the mid-second century CE when veneration of Mary and curiosity about her origins were growing trends in many Christian circles, this Gospel provides not only the names of Mary’s parents and the manner of her extraordinary birth and upbringing but also a doctrine of her perpetual virginity. 

Divided into three approximately equal parts, the Infancy Gospel of James is largely a prose hymn of praise to Mary the Virgin, regarded as the most divinely favored of all women. 

The first section recounts the divine intervention that resulted in Mary’s miraculous birth to Joachim and Anna and the immaculate purity of her Temple childhood; the second part explores the perplexities that Mary and Joseph faced in their unusual life together. 

Although the narrator emphasizes that Joseph is only Mary’s devoted protector, not her husband, their relationship becomes particularly complicated after an angel visits Mary, announcing that she will bear a child conceived by the Holy Spirit. 

When Joseph returns home from a long absence at work to find that Mary is six months pregnant, he agonizes over his apparent failure to protect her virginity. 

Composing a lively conversation between the almost equally bewildered – and celibate – pair, the author creates a scene that combines sensitivity to the plight of a human couple caught up in forces beyond their control and the inescapable humor inherent in their strange predicament. 

Interspersing elements from the canonical infancy stories with his own special material, the narrator devotes the final third of his Gospel to an account of Jesus’ birth at Bethlehem, closing with Herod’s murderous attempt to eliminate a future rival. 

As if to guarantee the historicity of his account, the writer then reveals that he is none other than James (whom Paul calls “the Lord’s brother”), the son of Joseph by his deceased wife. 

This final section contains a scene in which two midwives examine Mary after she has given birth to Jesus, discovering, to their astonishment, that she is still physically a virgin. 

Traditional lore about Mary incorporated into the Infancy Gospel of James probably contributed significantly to the unique position that Jesus’ mother eventually held in both the Greek Orthodox and Roman Catholic churches. 

Its immense popularity in the church is reflected in the Gospel’s survival in over 130 Greek manuscripts. 

Although never officially admitted to the New Testament canon, in some Christian groups the book has had as much influence in shaping orthodox belief as have the canonical Gospels. 

The Diatesseron

A Christian scholar named Tatian (c. 170 CE) compiled a single Gospel for the congregations of Syria. 

Tatian drew primarily on the four Gospels that eventually became canonical, but he also utilized some material from a lost work called the History of Joseph the Carpenter and a “Hebrew Gospel.” 

Called the Diatesseron, Tatian’s selective harmonizing of the Gospels may have eliminated some of the problems of repetition, contradiction, and theological dissimilarity that characterize the four disparate accounts now included in the New Testament. 

Although Tatian’s harmonization was popular in Syria, the international church did not adopt it, and by the late fourth century, even the Syrian Christians had replaced it with the four canonical Gospels. 

Some Other Portrayals of Jesus…

H.B. Warner in the 1927 silent film King of Kings
Jeffrey Hunter in the 1961 film King of Kings
Max von Sydow in the 1965 film The Greatest Story Ever Told
Ted Neeley in the 1973 musical film Jesus Christ Superstar
Robert Powell in the 1977 miniseries Jesus of Nazareth
Brian Deacon in the 1979 film Jesus
Henry Ian Cusick in the 2003 film The Gospel of John
Jim Caviezel in the 2004 film The Passion of the Christ











______________________________________________________________


Sources

Stephen L. Harris. The New Testament: A Student's Introduction (6th ed.). McGraw-Hill: New York, NY, 2009.